Neurobiological and Philosophical Foundations for a Post-Republican Psychology
Neurobiological and Philosophical Foundations for a Post-Republican Psychology
Post-Republican Psychology
Neurobiological and Philosophical Foundations for a Post-Republican Psychology: Lessons from Indigenous Critiques and Relational Neuroscience
(Revised and expanded with insights from *The Dawn of Everything* by David Graeber and David Wengrow)
Introduction: Enlightenment’s Hidden Debt to Indigenous Thought
The European Enlightenment, often celebrated as the birthplace of modern ideals like freedom and democracy, is frequently framed as a purely endogenous intellectual revolution. However, emerging scholarship—notably in The Dawn of Everything (Graeber & Wengrow, 2021)—reveals how these ideas were profoundly shaped by encounters with Indigenous American societies. Through dialogues with Indigenous leaders, European thinkers were challenged to reimagine social organization beyond rigid hierarchies. For example, Wendat (Huron) philosophers critiqued European materialism and authoritarianism, while Indigenous models of participatory governance and fluid social structures offered tangible alternatives to monarchical rule.
This historical revisionism dismantles the myth of Western intellectual exceptionalism and invites us to rethink foundational psychological frameworks still rooted in Enlightenment-era dualisms. In this essay, I argue for a **post-republican psychology** that bridges neurobiological advances (embodied cognition, predictive processing, relational neuroscience) with philosophical insights from societies that long practiced decentralized, relational modes of being.
The Republican Legacy: Cartesian Dualism and the Myth of Autonomy
Classical republican philosophy, from Rousseau to Kant, hinges on a Cartesian split: mind vs. body, individual vs. collective, reason vs. emotion. This framework birthed a psychology of abstract individualism, where the "self" is a bounded, rational agent navigating social contracts—a view mirrored in Enlightenment political theory. Yet, as Graeber and Wengrow illustrate, many Indigenous Amerindian societies operated through fluid, non-coercive systems that rejected fixed hierarchies and emphasized collective well-being over individual autonomy.
Republican models of psychology—like their political counterparts—often pathologize interdependence, framing emotions, traditions, and social bonds as threats to rational self-governance. This perpetuates a false dichotomy between "autonomous minds" and "disorderly bodies," ignoring how cognition and identity are *constituted through relationality*.
Embodied Cognition: The Mind-Body-Culture Continuum
Modern neuroscience dismantles Cartesian dualism. Embodied cognition posits that thought emerges from sensorimotor engagement with the world—not from a disembodied "rational self." For instance, the insula integrates visceral states into decision-making, while mirror neurons scaffold empathy through embodied simulation. Similarly, Indigenous practices like communal dance, ritual, and collective labor reflect an understanding of cognition as distributed across bodies and ecologies.
Predictive processing further radicalizes this: the brain is not a solitary decoder of reality but a *relational organ* that predicts the world through continuous dialogue with its social and environmental niche. This aligns with Indigenous epistemologies where "knowledge" is co-created through dynamic participation in community and land—a stark contrast to the republican ideal of the lone, deliberative citizen.
Relational Neuroscience: Toward a Psychology of Interbeing
Cutting-edge research in relational neuroscience reveals that the brain’s structure and function are shaped by social experiences. The default mode network (DMN), for example, undergirds self-referential thought but is attenuated during communal activities, suggesting that "selfhood" diminishes in states of collective flow. Oxytocin and serotonin systems, critical for emotional regulation, are modulated by social safety and reciprocity—not individual willpower.
These findings resonate with Indigenous cosmologies that prioritize kinship networks and mutual aid over individualism. The Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) Confederacy, a model of participatory democracy admired by Enlightenment thinkers, institutionalized interdependence through clan-based governance and consensus-building. Likewise, neurobiological principles refute the republican psyche, illustrating that well-being hinges on relational coherence, not self-mastery.
Conclusion: A Post-Republican Psychology for an Interconnected World
Graeber and Wengrow’s work urges us to see the Enlightenment not as a European triumph but as a cross-cultural dialogue—one where Indigenous critiques exposed the limitations of hierarchical governance and mechanistic worldviews. Similarly, a post-republican psychology must reject the fiction of the autonomous self, integrating instead:
1. Embodied realism: Cognition as an ecological, socially embedded process.
2. Relational ethics: Well-being as contingent on communal reciprocity.
3. Pluralistic frameworks: Knowledge systems beyond Western individualism.
By weaving neurobiology with Indigenous philosophies, we might finally craft a psychology that honors our interdependence—a science not of isolated minds, but of interbeing.
References
- Graeber, D., & Wengrow, D. (2021). The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
- Clark, A. (2015). Surfing Uncertainty: Prediction, Action, and the Embodied Mind. Oxford University Press.
- Tognoli, E., & Kelso, J. A. S. (2014). The metastable brain. Neuron, 81(1), 35-48.
- Tallbear, K. (2015). Standing with and Speaking as Faith: A Feminist-Indigenous Approach to Inquiry. Journal of Research Practice.
This revision centers Indigenous contributions to Enlightenment thought while grounding post-republican psychology in robust neurobiological and anthropological evidence.
Bases Neurobiológicas para una Reconexión Integral del Ser Humano - Psicología Quórum
Neurobiological Foundations for the Whole Human Being Reconnection
Apus como Interface Neurofisiológica - A Propriocepção Estendida na Relação Corpo-Espaço
CONBRAMENE 2025 Congress
CONBRAMENE 2025 Congreso Brasileño de Metabolismo y Nutrición Deportiva
CONBRAMENE 2025 - Metabolismo Movimento e Consciência
CONBRAMENE 2025 - Metabolism Movement, and Consciousness
CONBRAMENE 2025 - Metabolismo, Movimiento y Conciencia
CONBRAMENE 2025 - Feelings are Metabolism Modulated by Nutrition and Movement
CONBRAMENE 2025 - Los sentimientos son metabolismo modulado por la nutrición y el movimiento
Páscoa para Lembrar ou para Esquecer
Como Nossa Consciência e Conectomas Nos Ajudam a Decidir
A Neurobiologia da Democracia Cognitiva - Dinâmica dos Conectomas e Coletivos Funcionais
Consciência Executiva, Legislativa e Jurídica com Alteração na Liderança
Democracia Real em Coletivos Funcionais
Nueva Psicología Posrepublicana
Nova Psicologia Pós-Republicana
Neurobiological and Philosophical Foundations for a Post-Republican Psychology
Bases Neurobiológicas e Filosóficas para uma Nova Psicologia Pós-Republicana
#Decolonial
#Neuroscience
#CorpoEspaço
#CONBRAMENE2025
#NeuroMetabolismo
#MovimentoConsciente
#Neurodemocracia
#FilosofiaDaMente
#EraPósRepublicana
#ConectomasSociais
#Neuropolítica
#DrexCidadão
#Drex
#PsicologiaQuórum
#ConsciênciaColetiva
