The Memory That Returns Never Encounters Exactly the Same Brain
The Memory That Returns Never Encounters Exactly the Same Brain
Engrams, aversive memories, and updating: how information from the present can become part of what we remember next.
The Blue Cup and the Unexpected Revelation
You find a blue cup forgotten in a cupboard. It reminds you of an unpleasant conversation. Before you can explain why, you notice your body becoming alert. An old voice seems to return, your attention abandons the task, and other scenes begin to emerge.
Then someone tells you something you never knew about that episode. The person you considered hostile, for example, was facing a difficult situation that day, something you were unaware of. When you encounter the cup again weeks later, your memory may already include this information.
The object remains much the same. But the memory has encountered a different present, one capable of participating in its updating.
At BrainLatam, we want to investigate this encounter without confusing three phenomena: reactivating a memory, modifying present experience, and producing changes that persist in subsequent retrievals.
The Experiment: The Present Enters a Remote Memory
In 2025, Bo Lei and colleagues tracked memory-related neuronal ensembles in mice, using cellular tagging across successive events and two-photon imaging.
The researchers observed that retrieving a remote memory could recruit a new ensemble of hippocampal engram cells. This recruitment participated in updating the memory with new contextual information, influencing subsequent retrieval.
The finding is crucial: remembering does not necessarily mean reactivating, unchanged, the circuit involved in the original learning experience.
Nor does it mean that every recollection is automatically rewritten. The study involved specific experimental conditions and animal models. Nevertheless, it demonstrates a material possibility: information from the present can become integrated into circuits involved in what will be remembered later.
Memory, Engram, and Remembering Are Not Synonyms
Memory refers to processes through which previous experiences influence learning, behavior, and information retrieval.
An engram refers to persistent material, cellular, and circuit-level changes that participate in forming, maintaining, and potentially retrieving a particular memory. It is not a photograph stored inside an isolated cell.
Remembering is an event in which current cues and states facilitate the reactivation of components of these organizations, allowing a learned response or conscious experience.
An engram may persist without a narratable recollection. A person may display learned responses without autobiographically reconstructing an episode. And conscious retrieval may recruit neural organizations partially different from those involved during encoding.
Therefore, stored memory, memory processing, and the experience of remembering require different questions and measurements.
Hebb: Coactivation Is Not Destiny
The principle associated with Donald Hebb is often summarized as “neurons that fire together strengthen their connections.” Scientifically, plasticity depends on the temporal coordination of activity and appropriate cellular and neuromodulatory conditions.
When a memory-related ensemble is active while new information is being processed, opportunities for establishing associations may emerge. This can involve synaptic strengthening or weakening, recruitment of additional cells, and network reorganization.
However, coactivation does not guarantee stronger connections or lasting change. Reconsolidation depends on specific circumstances, including novelty or discrepancies between expectations and outcomes.
The importance of Lei's experiment lies in providing a causal example of remote memory updating rather than assuming that updating occurs whenever we remember.
Context Also Changes What We Retrieve
In November 2026, Molly Hermiller and Lila Davachi published a human study using functional magnetic resonance imaging.
Participants learned objects associated with particular scenes. Later, they encountered those objects again in identical or different contexts before attempting to identify the original scene.
Intermediate changes in context influenced subsequent judgments about the memory's origin. Object recognition, however, did not show an equivalent difference.
The study distinguishes knowing that we have seen something from accurately remembering where we encountered it. It also shows that the contextual state during retrieval may participate in future judgments.
This provides an opportunity to ask how Situatedness, within our APUS hypothesis, enters the experience of remembering—without claiming that the study has validated APUS.
When an Object Recruits an Aversive Memory
The blue cup may be a cue associated with an unpleasant experience, even though it poses no danger in the present.
In 2025, Manuela Costa and colleagues recorded intracranial activity in humans and found, during the retrieval of aversive scenes, hippocampal gamma patterns related to amygdala activity during the original encoding.
This finding connects mechanisms of contextual and emotional memory. But it does not mean that any object necessarily produces complete reactivation of the past or that every defensive response corresponds to consciously experienced fear.
A person may feel discomfort, change their breathing, or avoid an object without recalling a detailed narrative. Another person may remember the event clearly and reinterpret it in light of new information.
What returns is influenced by the organism's history and present conditions.
Astroengrams: Memory Does Not Depend on Neurons Alone
In 2026, Javier Sánchez Romero and Marta Navarrete reviewed evidence concerning ensembles of astrocytes recruited during learning, known as astroengrams.
These cells do not replace neurons, but their interactions with neural circuits may participate in memory stability and retrieval. Previous studies had already demonstrated effects of manipulating astrocyte ensembles on recall in animal models.
This challenges the simplistic image of a fixed, exclusively neuronal engram. Memory involves multicellular and temporal processes whose contributions are still being investigated.
The Representational Space That Expands During Remembering
A small cup can trigger an extensive internal organization: a voice, a place, an expectation, consequences, and possibilities for action.
Within 5D Consciousness, these processes exist within the three-dimensional spatial materiality of the Body-Territory. The Movement dimension also includes the material transformations of abstractions during Doing and remembering. The Qualia dimension corresponds to the subjective quality of experience, which may or may not receive attentional prominence.
When we say that a memory gains representational space, we do not necessarily mean that its anatomical volume increases. Our hypothesis concerns the expansion of relationships and functional influence among distributed processes.
Attention may shift toward this internal organization and, reciprocally, reinforce some of its relationships. An aversive experiential quality may be present without dominating the entire attentional focus.
Being, Situatedness, and Perception During Memory Retrieval
Tekoha names our hypothesis of extended interoception, associated with Being; APUS names our hypothesis of extended proprioception, associated with Situatedness.
When encountering the cup again, bodily conditions, relationships with the environment, and perceptual experience jointly participate in the event. Perception transforms Being and Situatedness while being transformed by both.
These are not sequential stages. Their separation is methodological: in conscious experience, they constitute a symbiosis.
In dialogue with the Damasian Mind and Feeling & Knowing, we preserve our original formulation: “Consciousness is a movement that perceives itself as being within the metabolism that produces it.” Engram activity alone does not demonstrate this experience.
Metanoia: From the Present to the Next Memory
In condition A, the cup evokes an earlier interpretation. In B, new information is presented while the memory is active. In A', when encountering the cup again, the person may also retrieve aspects of the incorporated information.
Here we distinguish two outcomes: an immediate change in the perceptual present and a persistent updating of memory. They may occur together, but they are not equivalent.
We call Metanoia our hypothesis concerning the reorganization that participates in constructing the present during the transition, not merely afterward. Engram updating provides experimental mechanisms with which to establish a dialogue, without being synonymous with Metanoia.
Perturbation, Reserve, and New Questions
In 2026, Zhuoran Li and colleagues demonstrated that parietal TMS guided by functional connectivity can evoke and modulate hippocampal responses. They did not demonstrate the erasure of aversive memories or the production of specific recollections.
Roberto Lent, Fernanda Tovar-Moll, and Diego Szczupak proposed the Connectomic Reserve as a potential source of connections that are not strongly expressed functionally but may participate in reorganization.
These studies suggest new questions: which conditions favor additional recruitment during retrieval? Can face-to-face dialogue enable relationships that did not emerge during solitary remembering? How can we distinguish temporary change, additional learning, and persistent updating?
The Relational Connectomic Reserve is our hypothetical extension, not an established result.
The Next Experiment
We could teach associations between objects and scenes, introduce new information during controlled retrieval, and test memory on another day. We would compare stable contexts, altered contexts, and face-to-face interaction, using behavioral measurements, subjective reports, EEG, and autonomic responses.
Changes should not be induced through traumatic experiences. It would also be necessary to distinguish the original memory, incorporated information, and confusion about the source.
An engram can participate in incorporating the present. But the decisive question is when that incorporation changes what we will remember next.
Annotated References
1. Lei, B., Kang, B., Hao, Y. et al. (2025). Reconstructing a new hippocampal engram for systems reconsolidation and remote memory updating. Neuron.
This is the central reference for the revised article. Using neuronal ensemble tagging across three events and two-photon microscopy, the researchers tracked changes associated with memory acquisition, retrieval, and updating in mice.
Their results showed that retrieving a remote memory could recruit a new hippocampal engram ensemble involved in subsequent retrieval. Present contextual information could participate in this new organization.
The study provides experimental evidence that remembering can create opportunities for updating. However, it does not demonstrate that every conscious human retrieval automatically modifies existing engrams.
2. Hermiller, M. S. & Davachi, L. (2026). Intervening contexts reshape hippocampal-cortical retrieval states and later source attribution. Journal of Neuroscience.
This study investigated how intermediate contexts modify subsequent judgments about the origin of previously learned objects.
Using functional magnetic resonance imaging, the researchers examined representational patterns during retrieval in stable or altered contexts.
The most interesting finding for BrainLatam is that the context present during retrieval can influence future judgments about where an experience occurred.
This provides an opportunity to investigate the relationship between memory and Situatedness (APUS), while maintaining the distinction between experimental evidence and our original interpretation.
3. Costa, M. et al. (2025). Human hippocampal reactivation of amygdala encoding-related gamma patterns during aversive memory retrieval. Nature Communications, 16.
This is the main reference for the discussion of aversive memories.
Using human intracranial recordings, the researchers identified hippocampal gamma activity patterns during the retrieval of aversive scenes that were related to activity previously observed in the amygdala during encoding.
The study provides evidence concerning communication between structures involved in memory and emotional processing.
For our hypothesis, it allows us to ask how an object may recruit processes associated with an aversive experience, modifying attention and bodily responses.
It does not establish that every activation of these networks is accompanied by aversive Qualia.
4. Sánchez Romero, J. & Navarrete, M. (2026). Astroengrams: rethinking the cellular substrate for memory. Nature Reviews Neuroscience.
This review introduces an important development in understanding the cellular substrates of memory.
The authors discuss evidence of astrocyte ensembles associated with learning, retrieval, and the stability of particular memories, proposing the concept of astroengrams.
Its main contribution is to expand an explanation traditionally centered on neurons to include interactions among different cell populations.
At BrainLatam, this perspective supports a material and dynamic understanding of engrams without treating astrocytes and neurons as functionally equivalent components.
5. Systems consolidation reorganizes hippocampal engram circuitry (2025). Nature.
In this study, researchers used engram-identification tools in mice to investigate how hippocampal circuits change over time.
They observed reorganizations associated with memory precision and the possibility of responding to situations similar, but not identical, to the original learning experience.
The finding is important because it demonstrates that the material organization associated with a memory does not necessarily remain unchanged.
It also helps distinguish changes resulting from consolidation over time from those produced specifically during retrieval.
6. Li, Z. et al. (2026). Multimodal evidence for hippocampal engagement and modulation by functional connectivity-guided parietal TMS. Nature Communications, 17.
This research used transcranial magnetic stimulation over parietal regions individually selected according to their functional connectivity with the hippocampus.
Combining intracranial recordings and neuroimaging, the researchers identified evoked hippocampal responses and changes in theta activity following repetitive stimulation.
The study demonstrates the possibility of modulating components of a deep network through cortical stimulation.
It does not establish that TMS can erase a particular aversive memory or insert specific information into an engram.
Its importance lies in providing tools for investigating causal relationships between perturbation and functional organization.
7. Lent, R., Tovar-Moll, F. & Szczupak, D. (2026). The secret connections of the brain: a connectomic reserve for neuroplasticity?. Brain, 149(7), 2273–2285.
The Brazilian researchers propose the Connectomic Reserve hypothesis, involving distributed connections that may offer additional possibilities for functional reorganization.
Their proposal expands questions concerning plasticity and individual differences, particularly when circumstances require strategies that have not previously been expressed.
Within Blog 06, the hypothesis inspires investigations into the recruitment of alternative pathways during memory retrieval.
However, it is not evidence that forgotten memories remain intact within hidden circuits.
BrainLatam's Relational Connectomic Reserve is a distinct extension that requires its own experimental validation.
8. Hebb, D. O. (1949). The Organization of Behavior: A Neuropsychological Theory.
This influential work introduced a framework for associative learning and the strengthening of connections between neural elements whose activity exhibits systematic relationships.
Its historical importance for Blog 06 is that it provides a conceptual foundation for investigating how the coactivation of cell populations may favor new associations.
However, the so-called Hebbian rule does not explain all neural plasticity on its own. Synaptic strengthening, weakening, neuromodulation, and other physiological conditions participate in memory formation and updating.
9. Damásio, A. (2021). Feeling & Knowing: Making Minds Conscious.
António Damásio discusses how bodily feelings, images, and processes of knowing contribute to constructing conscious experience.
His contribution to our discussion lies in distinguishing physiological processes associated with memory from the subjective experience of remembering.
A retrieved memory occurs within a living organism with bodily states, expectations, and relationships with its environment.
At BrainLatam, we establish a dialogue with this perspective while preserving the independence of our definition of consciousness and the 5D Consciousness hypothesis.
10. BrainLatam Hypothesis - 5D Consciousness, Metanoia, APUS, Tekoha, and the Relational Connectomic Reserve.
Our proposal investigates how a reactivated memory may participate in incorporating information from the present and, under certain conditions, influence future retrieval.
The three-dimensional materiality of the Body-Territory provides the spatial conditions for physiological processes. The Movement dimension includes material transformations associated with representations, abstractions, and Doing. The Qualia dimension corresponds to the subjective quality of experience.
Being (Tekoha), Situatedness (APUS), and Perception are not independent stages. They participate in a symbiosis undergoing continuous transformation.
Metanoia is our hypothesis concerning the reorganization occurring during the construction of the perceptual present itself, whereas persistent engram updating constitutes a distinct experimental possibility.
We therefore propose investigating which conditions favor the incorporation of new information, when that updating persists, and how social encounters may modify retrieval pathways.
The central scientific distinction remains: reactivating an engram can create conditions for incorporating information from the present, but persistent memory updating is not guaranteed by every retrieval.
This English edition preserves the dialogue among Hebbian plasticity, aversive memories, astroengrams, the Damasian Mind, and BrainLatam's Metanoia hypothesis, while keeping established research findings separate from the proposed 5D Consciousness framework.
BRAINLATAM · W48/2026 · GRAND SUMMARY SfN 2026 · BLOG 06 · ENGLISH EDITION
#eegmicrostates #neurogliainteractions #eegmicrostates #eegnirsapplications #physiologyandbehavior #neurophilosophy #translationalneuroscience #bienestarwellnessbemestar #neuropolitics #sentienceconsciousness #metacognitionmindsetpremeditation #culturalneuroscience #agingmaturityinnocence #affectivecomputing #languageprocessing #humanking #fruición #wellbeing #neurophilosophy #neurorights #neuropolitics #neuroeconomics #neuromarketing #translationalneuroscience #religare #physiologyandbehavior #skill-implicit-learning #semiotics #encodingofwords #metacognitionmindsetpremeditation #affectivecomputing #meaning #semioticsofaction #mineraçãodedados #soberanianational #mercenáriosdamonetização